The proposed EU law Chat Control will not only create a centralized mass surveillance system and violate people's privacy. It will also ban open source operating systems as an unintended consequence.

If and when this law goes into effect it would make illegal the open source software services underpinning the majority of services and infrastructure on the internet.

Learn more here: mullvad.net/blog/2023/2/1/eu-c

@mullvadnet I think some inconvenience is possible, but you exaggerate.

@midgephoto @mullvadnet A "software application store" is defined by Article 2[*] to mean "a type of online intermediation services, which is focused on software applications as the intermediated product or service".

Article 6 of the law requires all "software application stores" to:

Assess whether each service provided by each software application enables human-to-human communication
Verify whether each user is over or under the age of 17
Prevent users under 17 from installing such communication software

I'm assuming "verify" means more than "Are you over 16? [N/y]". Gonna need to register an ID to run pacman

@applejack @midgephoto @mullvadnet @applejack @midgephoto @mullvadnet in the EU anyway. like the GDPR it won't hold any weight globally. it would mean many FOSS projects couldn't realistically be headquartered in the EU anymore. and if the governments there decided to take enforcement seriously then ISPs would likely be forced to block the respective websites

it would be pretty amusing if debian.org was blocked in the EU the same way sci-hub is in many countries
Follow

@roboneko @mullvadnet @midgephoto But people actually comply with GDPR. Tons of sites were blocked temporarily while they set stuff up, you can request to view or delete your data on services via dedicated buttons like on Discord and Twitter (IIRC). Some sites like Fox still block me

Тons of free software is based in Europe, including Mullvad here. If it's applied to people running software (I'm assuming so) and not just production, then people won't be able to run distros, host servers

I also wonder how it's going to affect commits from people in the EU to projects outside it

I guess the exact degree of awful depends on the specifics, but it's an awful law

· · Web · 1 · 0 · 3
@applejack @midgephoto @mullvadnet @applejack @mullvadnet @midgephoto that was because those for-profit companies wished to be able to do business in the EU so they had no choice but to comply. even ones that aren't there right now likely want to preserve their ability to expand there in the future. whereas FOSS can be headquartered wherever. they aren't generally profit-driven. if I start a project and an EU person contributes or clones or installs it and that's illegal for them that's their problem not mine

I mean I suppose the EU could threaten to bar me from traveling there or something. but there's just not much they can realistically threaten me with as someone not directly subject to their rule

but yeah completely agreed it's an absolutely awful idea for a law. but it's happening there instead of in the US so I can sit back and watch the show :ablobpopcorn:
Sign in to participate in the conversation
Game Liberty Mastodon

Mainly gaming/nerd instance for people who value free speech. Everyone is welcome.