I used to deeply hate tutorials, and thought, that the only important part of the game is the ability to skip them.

But, I was just re-playing the Phantom Pain, and I realized, that it was absolute cinema. And then, it hit me. The problem with tutorials was never the length. It was actually something worse. It was pacing. Tutorial is a job, that you're required to do before you're invested in the game. And worse? It is placed after another job. The character creation. And EVEN WORSE? Character creation is before even basic understanding of the game can be established.

So, what would be an ideal order? Well, literally all the best games pull you in even before you start playing. In Oblivion for example, you find out your situation, play for a half hour, and only after that, you must lock in the important stuff. That is healthy.

A good tutorial is where you don't notice it, like Oblivion or Skyrim. The problem is not every game used to need one, but apparently now they do.
On the other hand for example, I never got into BioShock games, because the entire first game felt like a neverending tutorial. They're holding your hand and introducing abilities during each level, and suddenly you beat the game and it's over.
Follow

@skiizm
What a great callback.
I remember when I played Bioshock infinite. It had a slow start, but after some hours, I remember, when it finally clicked. I loved the feeling of free flow shooting and movement. A thought of "Finally the tutorial is over, and I can enjoy the actual game". It felt GREAT.

Then I realized, that this exact moment was unironically and literally during the final boss fight. -_-

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Game Liberty Mastodon

Mainly gaming/nerd instance for people who value free speech. Everyone is welcome.