@sex@neckbeard.xyz
>Halting sex hormone production, isn't harmful aside from temporarily stalling sexually development
And that's where you've been misinformed. Puberty blockers weren't designed to be used the way they are being used on trans-kids. They were designed to postpone puberty for a small duration of time, not the entire length of it. And they were designed for children that had some kind of imbalance that made them produce too much hormone or too soon, to help fix the imbalance, not completely eliminate hormones off the table. Their safety for transition therapy hasn't been proven in any way, and we're still some time of before we'll start seeing enough studies on the effects on the currently affected children to know for sure.

But thing is, it's hard to see how they wouldn't have negative side effects, especially on one's mental health. When a child is most sensitive about things like how they look or sex, you're gonna condemn them to look like a weird androgynous big child, instead of developing either as a male or female? God only knows how much ostracization one could get.

As for the biological part, hormones play such a big part in how our entire body develop, not just the outside looks, but bone structure and all that. Again, we know basically nothing about what the consequences will be. One thing we do know already though, males that did it, and didn't fully develop between their legs, found out later on that they couldn't get bottom surgery, because the doctors didn't have enough material to work with.

>So that their body isn't developed in either direction, until they grow up further, and can make a more informed choice.
The problem I have with this, is that you're affecting so much the biological and mental development of the person, that I'm not sure if they would actually make an informed choice. Emphasis on informed. If you didn't get to experience any kind of male puberty, how can you be sure that it would have been wrong for you? When the most important years of your development have been a constant push for you to be a girl, with no real experience of physically being a man, where exactly is the informed part of your choice? To me it sounds more like a breeding ground for manipulation and brainwashing. And you might want to look into the statistics of just how many children that express some kind of gender dysphoria grow out of it once they go through puberty. To save you the hassle, it's somewhere around 80% IIRC.

@alyx @sex At one time, people castrated children to make them into a certain type of singer. We now see that as horrific. We'll have to wait and see a generation from now how these puberty blockers work out, but I think it's much more likely they'll be see as equally horrific has castrato singers.
Follow

@djsumdog @sex@neckbeard.xyz
As they say, history is written by the victors. I honestly don't know how future generations will view this, and I'm afraid to try to make a prediction. All I know is how I view this phenomenon currently. And I don't like it.

· · Web · 0 · 0 · 1
Sign in to participate in the conversation
Game Liberty Mastodon

Mainly gaming/nerd instance for people who value free speech. Everyone is welcome.