@rasterman i still think goty will likely go to starfield. if it went to baldur's gate that would be really weird considering it's been in early access for at least a couple years now. i don't think it's fair for those kinds of games to get goty.
i say starfield will likely take goty because as long as it isn't a steaming pile of shit people will probably eat it up and you'll have some recency bias there.
i don't necessarily think zelda is goty material either though, i mean it's really good but damn that story is fucking bad. the core gameplay hard carries it. compare it to something like elden ring... i don't even like souls games but i think elden ring is probably a better game objectively speaking.
i wouldn't be surprised if baldur's gate is actually the better game, though i haven't played it yet. just because it has bear sex doesn't mean it isn't objectively a game with better mechanics and a better story with more meaningful content for its long runtime. haven't played it so i don't know, but man i haven't even beaten zelda yet and it really wore me out.
@rasterman i already lost my foreskin and have a big beard, maybe i could infiltrate their ranks
@rasterman also interesting to note how fast the whole "game of the year" thing transitioned from being given out by all these different news outlets to the only one actually meaning anything being the one at the game awards. sure, the public "technically" votes for it but they still have a panel and everything. it was more interesting when it was more dispersed, imo.