Ocarina of Time Remake Review (9.5/10) 

Not only did Nintendo just create the greatest remake of all time, they did it with one of the best and most beloved games of all time. I truly believe that this is hands down better than the original game, with very few hiccups along the way. When people ask what Zelda game to play first now, I'm no longer going to give my "Ocarina of Time or Breath of the Wild" answer, depending on what kind of gameplay they are after. Ocarina of Time's remake is the answer I'll give everyone now. It's incredible.

Aside from the obvious graphical overhaul, which is so whimsical and very appreciated in a gaming landscape where we either get retro-inspired games or realistic looking ones, Nintendo have gone absolutely bonkers with this remake without adding anything that might upset the original's balance. The most worthy thing to note are the new cutscenes, which add so much gravitas to the story and so much extra characterization to the denizens of Hyrule. Things like the Great Deku Tree's death, pulling the Master Sword for the first time, and a lot of the ending are completely revamped and recontextualized in a way that feels much more impactful.

Speaking of characterization, holy crap Navi got quite the glow-up here. At first, I found her little quips pretty annoying because she is just repeating stuff Solid Snake style, but as time went on you start to get a feel for her personality where she's always just trying to be bright and funny, very fairy-like. In the original, she can be a bit of an annoying guide constantly pestering you about stuff you need to do or game systems, and that's about it, minus a couple more interesting interactions. She was primarily made for the same reason Lakitu in Mario 64 was, to give very new concepts a character to associate with that made them feel more grounded for the new players. In the remake, she's a full-blown character with tons of dialogue, tons of personality, who often speaks on Link's behalf which is a FANTASTIC idea for keeping him silent in a game that otherwise has voiced dialogue in cutscenes. I ended up really liking her new characterization a lot.

The gameplay is smoothed over in a way that I think a lot of people might misinterpret to be "making the game easier" but I believe this is only a secondary effect. The original game's difficulty doesn't come from anything that was purposefully made to be difficult, but from the rough edges that were a result of when and how it was developed. Every instance of that I can think of has been completely remedied and it results in the pacing and flow of the game becoming even better than it was before.

There are even little things here and there that have been added that help guide the player. It's kind of interesting because people who have already played the original Ocarina of Time will already know what to do for every single piece of the game, given how extremely faithful it is, and with their expertise this is going to seem a lot easier because they don't have to put up with the relative clunkiness of the original anymore. However, for players that got into Zelda with the Wild era games, the kinds of things that they have changed with the game design remind me a lot of how 3D games originally had to ease people into them. Haters will say it is too handholdy, but you gotta' remember who the handholding is for. It's not for players who have beaten the game over and over again. It's for the newer players who are used to a completely different style of game, much in the way the transition from 2D to 3D was but, paradoxically, it might even be a bigger jump than that. That is to say, it is easier for someone to grow up playing 2D games to transition to 3D games, than it is for someone to grow up playing modern 3D games to go back to an older style of 3D game. Just food for thought.

Anyway, I think it is easy to tell how much I love and respect this game. I had an absolute blast playing it, and because of how much experience I have with the original I never died and never really got stuck. It's a bit hard for me to tell how a new person playing the game would do in that regard, but I can certainly imagine kids especially having an appropriate level of challenge here and I think it is absolutely perfect for that.

That's not to say everything is sunshine and rainbows, though. I haven't given it a perfect score for a reason. There are some extremely minor issues that I think are easy enough to throw away in the grand criticism of things, which is exactly why I ended up giving Resident Evil Requiem a perfect score. However, there are some more glaring issues that, without the rest of the game being as good as it is, would have dropped the score lower for sure.

For one, Sheik is very obviously a woman in this game. I thought that was a really weird decision, but it could have been okay if nobody actually referred to Sheik as a man and it was just supposed to be a mysterious character. Nope, people still refer to Sheik as a guy. It creates a lot of dissonance. They really should have removed the ponytail, given her a bit more of a manly figure, and made sure that the person voicing her didn't obviously sound like a woman trying to make her voice deeper without it sounding unnatural. It feels like all the NPCs know that Sheik is a woman and are just gaslighting Link.

The other major issue happens to be the controls. Now, for the most part it is perfectly serviceable and I obviously was able to play the game well enough to never die. In fact I only ever actually had to use a single red potion. The game controls *fine* but the problem here is how much missed opportunity there was for it. There are buttons that are either unmapped or do the same things as other buttons. The dash and roll are both on A so if you want to dash you have to roll first unless you buffer it from another action and then while you're dashing you can only move the camera around if you switch to claw grip. Thankfully I was able to alleviate that with a custom binding on my right back button. Then you have the awful menu design for switching between things on the fly. It's an exact replica of the one from the Wild games and, while it works for those games because of the sheer amount of stuff you can have with a lot of variety at any given point, it really does not work for a game where you always have a set and ever-growing inventory with a bunch of tools that all do different things. In the original, during the Ganondorf battle I can have the Longshot on C-Up and the Light Arrows on C-Right, but in the remake you are REQUIRED to switch between them using that menu which adds unnecessary pausing to the flow of gameplay, which is ironically what they have tried to avoid with mapping boots, masks, and the Ocarina to the D-Pad. I feel like I could absolutely design a much better system than this. For instance, L and R both bring up that scrolling menu (which doesn't loop, by the way). They could have kept it as L and then made it so pressing L brings up the menu, where you can press R or ZR on an item to equip it to that button. Then, you'd at least have 2 slots for items at any given time. Going one step further, they could have made it a radial menu, or a grid menu, but instead it is this long line that doesn't even have the ability to swap categories. While we're at it, put dash on the left stick press as a toggle because the left stick press does literally nothing in normal gameplay. Also, an option for auto jumping would be nice too because even at the end of the game, my muscle memory would still take over sometimes and I would just run off a cliff instead of jumping manually.

The voice acting is also of varying quality, which I'm sure we're all used to when it comes to Nintendo at this point. There are some good and awkward line deliveries, but honestly it was still serviceable and there were some actors I really liked, for instance the Navi, Nabooru, and Zelda VAs all did a fantastic job.

These few things are stains on an otherwise perfect remake, and it sucks extra bad because I KNOW Nintendo could fix them quite easily but they absolutely will not, they never go back and fix stuff like this. If the rest of the game wasn't as absolutely amazing as it is, it would have a much lower score. Again, they're not game breaking or anything, but they're notable enough to bring up and that's why I can't give it a perfect score.

Playing this was really cool, altogether. I'll admit, I actually cried a little at the ending because I was struck with a really impactful thought. Most of the people who played the original did so when they were a kid. I played it in earnest when I was about as old as Link is in the game, though I had played it a little bit here and there at friends' houses before then and developed a lot of good memories doing so. Now, I have played a remade version as an adult, and got different things out of it than I did back then, but playing it definitely made me feel like a kid again in some ways, especially because I got to pretty much no-life it with a slow work week. Link gets sent to the past to be a child again, and be able to live out his childhood years, though obviously it won't ever be the same because he has all of the knowledge of the journey he had just taken. It got me thinking... that's exactly what this remake is to those of us who played it as a kid, isn't it? As adults, we have been taken back to the past to be a kid again, but with all the knowledge and experience we've gained since then. Ocarina of Time won't ever be the same as it was the first time we played it, but this is as close as you can get to reliving those same feelings. It felt really magical, that realization, and it is something that was done completely as a side effect of recreating a game like this with this exact messaging. Even though your adult life may have taken so many insane twists and turns, and you've got some crazy experiences, and maybe the things you dreamt about as a kid never came to fruition... and you'll never truly be able to relive your childhood... sometimes you can catch glimpses of it and it is very sweet. I don't know if any other game could possibly deliver such a message completely by mistake... it's almost as if the whole thing was setup from the very beginning even though it obviously wasn't. That's just the nature of good storytelling though, I think.

Anyway, yeah. I've rambled enough. The game is so fucking good. Some problems here and there, but I am such a huge fan of it. I'm glad it exists. It reignited my love for Zelda, and I really am happy to see that it is such a generational title. Everyone from Gen X to Gen Alpha now has their own version of Ocarina of Time that they can bond over and I think that is something really amazing, especially for a game that has the kind of messages that Ocarina of Time does. From the original, to the 3DS remake, to the Ship of Harkinian port, and then finally to this full fledged remake... it has always been a labor of love for one of video games' greatest titles, spanning nearly 30 years, and for damn good reason.

Ocarina of Time Remake Review (9.5/10) 

@beardalaxy@gameliberty.club "It reignited my love for Zelda" now go play the oracle games and help me petition nintendo to finish the trilogy!

Follow

Ocarina of Time Remake Review (9.5/10) 

@rosey the oracle games are actually some of the only ones i haven't played at all yet, alongside spirit tracks. i'd like to go back to back and play them at some point, but being gameboy games i think it'll be harder for me personally to get invested in them. before silent hill townfall and witcher 3 remastered came out, i was playing through twilight princess because i've never actually beaten it, and i've been making a really earnest attempt to despite not liking wolf link at all. i know there is a lot of sauce in there and that it is many people's favorite zelda game. so maybe once i beat twilight princess i'll go back to the oracle games and give them a shot. which one do you think would be the better one to start off with if i'm a little tentative going into it?

Ocarina of Time Remake Review (9.5/10) 

@beardalaxy@gameliberty.club probably ages, it's got the back and forth between the past and future like ocarina does which might hook you
if it helps ages is more puzzley and seasons is more action-oriented

Ocarina of Time Remake Review (9.5/10) 

@rosey i've heard people say that a lot, but then i've also seen a lot of people rather recently saying that's kind of bullshit. i'll take your word for it though. i think for a handheld game puzzles are probably going to work better than action does so yeah i might go with that first.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Game Liberty Mastodon

Mainly gaming/nerd instance for people who value free speech. Everyone is welcome.