@LukeAlmighty Had an argument with a dude on here fundamentally not understanding why that since I'm not Christian why don't I just kill myself lmao.

@Witch_Hunter_Siegfired
I will never let go of evangelists literally pointing on a tree, saying, that it is a proof of God :omegalul:

I was in a thread on Twitter where someone was asking what's the evidence for the existence of atoms.

I said this is smart, because most people hear it from their 3rd grade teacher and just take it on faith without ever asking for a justification...

Someone said "well because we can go to space and stuff is proof that the atomic model must be accurate"

When you really think about it, it's kind of the same vibe...
Follow

@cjd @LukeAlmighty @Witch_Hunter_Siegfired For someone in 3rd grade asking that is smart, but an adult should have learned elementary chemistry

· · Web · 1 · 0 · 0
Ok then, since you certainly learned it in elementary chemistry, maybe you can explain it...

Why is it more likely that everything is made of tiny atoms as opposed to everything being made of solid stuff ?

You can't just hand-wave and say "chemistry", as if the fact that carbon burns in oxygen somehow proves that the carbon and the oxygen are made out of tiny little pieces as opposed to, say, solid globs.

Tell me how we know that we're not living in a world where all observable laws of nature are the same, but atoms don't exist.

@cjd @LukeAlmighty @Witch_Hunter_Siegfired It does actually

If they did not exist as fixed units they would not be elements like oxygen and carbon, everything would exist as some infinite gradation of stuff

The fact we can write equations like:
CH4 + 2O2 -> CO2 + 2H20
And get equivalent results proves there is no infinite gradation

Also, did you not learn about how atoms were proved and their properties were discovered with brownian motion in chemistry class? Stuff like moles or gas laws in general would make 0 sense without atoms

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Game Liberty Mastodon

Mainly gaming/nerd instance for people who value free speech. Everyone is welcome.