b e a r d
holy shit my barbarian player just threw his greatsword toward a necromancer, rolled a nat 1, so the necro caught it and then proceeded to dimension door away 
bro is probably not gonna get his sword back... RIP it was a good one too. it'll be personal motivation to get back at the guy who stole it though at least xD
i just can't fuckin believe that happened lol, so funny
@apropos there's a really funny dynamic where this player will always have a funny idea of something to do, but probably not really. then another player will say "dude that would be so funny" so he's like "aight bet" and just goes for it xD it's made for so many funny moments of his character just being a complete dumbass. if they didn't want to keep going that route i don't think it would continue so i hope it is all just in good fun.
a lot of people think i'm a pretty ruthless DM but i think i usually just pick whatever outcome is most likely to happen lol. if a necromancer who is outnumbered and was going to teleport away at a certain point anyway has a sword thrown at him, he's going to pick it up and teleport away with it. the actual roll wasn't going to change that strategy it's just funny that the nat 1 happened so he could catch it lol.
>throw sword
>lose it
this was a just and proper result. Who taught this guy to use a sword? Some kind of barbarian?? There are things you do and things you don't do.