At least 90% of the Ocarina of Time remake's criticisms I've seen online have been that people think something is worse just because it is different, but they don't think about WHY it is different. Sometimes it's someone saying that something is easier than it was in the original when the original was either just as easy or easier. It just looks different so it's bad, for some reason, but they can't really tell you what the reasoning for changing it could have been outside of "well they just wanted to dumb it down because modern games are like that now." You cannot engage in a meaningful conversation about game design with someone like that.

@beardalaxy My biggest gripe is that most of the character designs look like shit. The only one that kind of stayed true to the original design was Impa. The worst offenders though are Link and Zelda. The "puppet show" design aesthetic was an awful idea courtesy of a woman of course.

@WhitestTemplar I really like the designs, they are very fairy tale like. It's something I've never seen in a game before. They're jarring so I get it, but I really like them.

@beardalaxy They don't feel integrated in the world. The style doesn't feel consistent. I would have rather they tried to emulate the style of the original concept art. At least then they could maybe justify doing a remake as the technology wasn't there to achieve the original graphical vision that they wanted. But that isn't what we got, instead we got a woman who had nothing to do with the original game deciding that because Miyamoto liked puppet theaters, to make some of the characters look like said puppets.
Follow

@WhitestTemplar I think it was an inspired decision that works really well for the dreamlike nature of the game and I don't give a single shit who came up with it.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Game Liberty Mastodon

Mainly gaming/nerd instance for people who value free speech. Everyone is welcome.