I really don't understand why the OOT remake is getting all this praise. The game looks ugly as sin, the puzzles and dungeons are more handholdy (the fucking Lost Woods has yellow paint notes), the environments don't accommodate the new controls (everything works fine with auto-jumping), and the game has micro-stutters when it's not even open-world like BoTW.
Just play Ship of Harkinian on PC. It's also available on the Switch and you can add a shit ton of mods and QoL features.
@xianc78 also dude the lost woods having "yellow paint notes" is such a nothing burger. It still uses the same audio system the original does and in the original you can tell if you're going the right way or not by standing halfway in the tunnel and if it has a fade then you go through, if it has a black void then you don't. It's still an extremely obvious visual indicator. Not too mention the original game LITERALLY has yellow paint telling you where to go in at least one area I can think of. Idk when the last time you played the game was but it's extremely handholdy because it was made for people who had never played that type of game before. Much in the same way that you could argue this one was, but kind of in the reverse direction. Made for kids who have to go backwards to traditional 3D Zelda instead of the modern ones. A lot of the design is streamlined where you would never have to do much extra in the original game but the design language is much more consistent now. The ice bridge is a perfect example, because in the original you only have to push a direction on the stick and Link will autojump, in the remake they kept the same inputs. The added jump button in that same section would have required more input from the player which is what they were trying to avoid, right up until the very end where you do have to jump once.
@pettanko @xianc78 it is, that's how I played the game up until like 2014. The thing is you have to account for people having their sound off, and with a handheld that's way more likely so you have to make the cue a bit more audience.
You know, a lot of people tend to complain about this stuff, but as soon as you remove it then it actually becomes a big issue. Seeing pretty hardcore gamers struggle a bunch with my game was pretty eye opening, I had to add a lot of stuff like this that I didn't think I would have to. I have to forcibly open the menu for people to learn how to equip their weapons otherwise they don't do it and are extremely weak, and then they criticize the game for being unfair. Same thing with areas that you can reach at a low level that have way harder enemies than you can currently take on. People thought the game was just too difficult and didn't think if they shouldn't be there or not. And that's completely on me as a designer, I just figured there were so many people that didn't want a game that holds their hand so I tried to avoid that.
@pettanko @xianc78 I wonder if it has something to do with skill-based games taking massive priority rather than games that have a heavier reliance on stats. Even with something like dark souls, your stats only serve to lower the amount of skill you need, whereas in an old school rpg you NEED to meet a certain level in order to not get immediately killed.
@beardalaxy
>in the original you can tell if you're going the right way or not by standing halfway in the tunnel and if it has a fade then you go through
I've noticed that, but I assumed it wasn't intentional and was only due to technical limitations. I don't recall either OOT or MM ever mentioning that and I don't think it was noticeable on CRTs.