Follow

Is there a single school, college, or university left that doesn't rely on Microsoft or Google for emails, calender, etc?

· · Web · 3 · 4 · 7
@xianc78 Outise the US, most public school utilize gov run platforms (But still rely on MS for OS/Office or Google for OS/Other services), but at least most critical info is on whatever platform their govs run.

Inside the US, no, those corporations have captured everything.

They would never use free software, because they can't sign contracts or draw guarantees from free software organizations. Besides, most school technicians are not trained into it.

I still remember a lab technician (Early 2010s) struggling to make VLC work on all computer lab computers (And she still never managed to)

@vokainen099 My Dad works in public education. The distract he worked for switched to Gmail a decade ago because of some law that required emails to be stored on their servers for 7 years and they didn't have the infrastructure to handle that.

@xianc78 They begun pushing for schools being full-digital back in the late 2000s (Financial crisis going and all that).

It probably was a gift to keep those corporations afloat, since it was easy to guess schools would be forced to rely on their services most of the time (Alas, transfer public money to them)

Email in particular, even if they had the infrastructure, it probably wouldn't work because of all those antispam safeguards google is enforcing
@xianc78 @vokainen099 they didn't have a $500 raid array for mailboxes? when goolag keels over i'm just gonna laugh at everything collapsing

@wowaname @vokainen099 @xianc78 yeah schools being able to afford 200 macs, 400 PCs, a dozen carts full of chromebooks, etc. but not being able to hold emails for 7 years seems a little weird to me.

@beardalaxy @vokainen099 @xianc78 it would 100% lower the budget required compared to renting gsuite on a contract
@wowaname @xianc78 Or it would have taken months to get the contract going, and in the meantime they would have been in the wrong, legally-wise.

Probably they just threw the towel

Also, those 100s of PCs are bought in batches with discounts

Edit: Also google anti-spam practices requiring DKIM and things like that
@vokainen099 @xianc78 dkim is set-and-forget especially when automated and done correctly (something even gmail refuses to do, last time i checked) so you're paying one sysadmin to get it running in a month's time and giving the rest of the nerds instructions on how to maintain shit if (if) it breaks
@wowaname @xianc78 Never tried it myself, but I've heard lots of (Inexperienced) mail server admins that DKIM just refuses to work sometimes. Of course, it may just be they didn't know what they were doing.

But, from a business perspective, school boards would just offshore everything to google to get whatever full package discount they can get (And maybe pocket the difference)

We reason as technologists, they reason (Badly) as businessmen

And, if something happens, they can offshore legal inquiries at google. Can't do that with free software.
@vokainen099 @xianc78 opendkim couldn't have been made much simpler to set up, in my experience. idk what enterprise crap everyone else uses, but if it's more complicated, idk what to tell them other than their priorities suck
@wowaname @xianc78 Enterprise software full of caveats, badly trained employees, unaware administrators, crony bosses, low budgeting, and general carelessness are the bread and butter of most workplaces these days
@vokainen099 @xianc78 which is why i don't even want to participate, and nobody irl understands why i choose poverty over it. i'm not gonna stress myself out swimming up the river, though, when i know my way is sustainable
@vokainen099 @xianc78 but nobody listens to my way cus they're averse to change. nothing gets done. so, let's pray those people go bankrupt, idgaf anymore
@wowaname @xianc78 Yeah, I won't blame you for pulling out. Indeed, most people don't pull out due to a sunk costs fallacy more or less
@vokainen099 @xianc78
>they can't sign contracts or draw guarantees from free software organizations.
i'm someone interested in bridging this gap, but nobody gave me enough interest to support my direction, and i never had enough money in my pocket to put toward initial funding myself.

@wowaname @vokainen099
>i'm someone interested in bridging this gap, but nobody gave me enough interest to support my direction, and i never had enough money in my pocket to put toward initial funding myself.

And the worst part about it is that there are organizations that could do it but choose not to. Disroot has been around for a decade now, runs on entirely free software, and is funded 100% by donations (some features are ONLY available if you donate though), but their ToS prohibits commercial use of their services with a few exceptions. I understand not wanting huge corpos using your service, but I see no problem with small businesses using it.

@wowaname @vokainen099 @xianc78 you also need to get rid of the normies who worship MSFT
"oh cool my office license also includes TEAMS time to shove this shit on people"
@realcaseyrollins @xianc78 last company i worked had reasons to in-house over NDAs and customer/contractor data. we handled important stuff. entrusting that shit to google and github at all was wrong.

education sector can get away with more, but from a budgeting standpoint, it makes no sense to put more money in google's pocket, especially considering how your whole staff have to receive training on how to use gsuite in the first place. do the numbers.
@realcaseyrollins @xianc78 furthermore, assuming a school has to keep its intranet running anyway, they're already halfway to keeping their mail infra up. that's one server in their networking room, next to their active directory and all that bullshit. the fear toward hosting mail is well overblown, i'm tired of it
@realcaseyrollins @xianc78
>security
hire me or someone else who has done this for years.
>failure to deliver
solved problem. they aren't that hard to get whitelisted for delivery.
@realcaseyrollins @xianc78 if an organisation has no security team, and they have a network, they need to fix that anyway. my university had a really good network security team and they even told us how quite a bit of it works (ingress/egress analysis, case studies, how responses to DMCA are handled)

just don't ignore this shit, as a CTO
Sign in to participate in the conversation
Game Liberty Mastodon

Mainly gaming/nerd instance for people who value free speech. Everyone is welcome.