Follow

At least 90% of the Ocarina of Time remake's criticisms I've seen online have been that people think something is worse just because it is different, but they don't think about WHY it is different. Sometimes it's someone saying that something is easier than it was in the original when the original was either just as easy or easier. It just looks different so it's bad, for some reason, but they can't really tell you what the reasoning for changing it could have been outside of "well they just wanted to dumb it down because modern games are like that now." You cannot engage in a meaningful conversation about game design with someone like that.

The combat is harder, by the way. King Dodongo spawns little dodongos you have to contest with while trying to throw the bomb into his mouth. ReDeads are faster and Sun Song has a much lower radius for stunning them. Phantom Ganon has a dive attack he uses more often and it's harder to initially tell which is the real one coming from the painting. Volvagia is just buffed across the board. Dark Link is more active in combat. Wolfos don't take any knockback. Enemies in pairs will generally attack you simultaneously more often instead of taking you one-on-one. Din's Fire no longer freezes everything else while the animation plays so you can still take damage. Hookshot doesn't auto kill Skulltulas anymore. There are probably other examples but those are what I noticed.

The only things I think got noticeably easier are that the flaming skulls are easier to dodge and keese aren't as aggressive, but honestly those two things could just be me misremembering how they acted in the original.

@beardalaxy I wonder how much of it is people just not playing the original in years so they misremember things. Like, it’s one thing to complain about the new game not having enough of a challenge, but to act like the original did is pretty silly. If they went back and played it they’d be shocked at how easy it is.

@pettanko deadass the only thing that gives the original any amount of challenge is old game design shit that was the result of none of this ever being done before.

@beardalaxy I dunno, I've played it so many times I'm used to its early 3D idiosyncrasies. I think about the only thing that gives me trouble is trying to kill Dark Link without just spamming Din's Fire.

please stop the cocksucking all the slopeaters and critics are already doing it. Just seeing it on autismverse is sad

@beardalaxy There's definitely quite a few instances of "streamlining"/dumbing down OoT, but I do feel that the online outrage about it is largely performative, given how many of these nerfs were already present in the 3DS remaster, so they were hardly surprising. Of course, the 3DS remaster DID include Master Quest, so that arguably made its changes much more excusable. However, none of the remake's actual combat difficulty buffs (as well as resource management actually becoming much more of a factor now) ever being acknowledged by the Haters does give me a very clear idea about their level of honesty. Obviously a very thorough difficulty rebalancing has been implemented here, rather than the whole game having been made easier.

youll both buy the next remake coming out in 2035. And then the one after than in 2045

@spasti @beardalaxy I mean, if it's an extremely high-effort remake of one of my Top 3 favorite games of all time... :shrug:

modern nintendo fans be like "actually graphics matter" lmao man

@spasti @ChristiJunior what was the last new release you played that you genuinely felt joy playing?

Final Fantasy Resonance in my Steam Machine

@ChristiJunior @beardalaxy Master Quest has been partially datamined, it's not fully there though IIRC. Apparently there's indication it could be added later. I'm hoping it will bring some big changes along with it, but I'm not hoping for much
@ChristiJunior @beardalaxy I do wonder what's going on with Master Quest though

Either:

1- Surprise drop, for free
2- It's DLC but it comes with significant changes

I know I'm hoping the moon for #2 since my vision for the remake didn't happen, but alas. I'd want them to fuck significantly with the game and not just the dungeons
@beardalaxy My biggest gripe is that most of the character designs look like shit. The only one that kind of stayed true to the original design was Impa. The worst offenders though are Link and Zelda. The "puppet show" design aesthetic was an awful idea courtesy of a woman of course.

@WhitestTemplar I really like the designs, they are very fairy tale like. It's something I've never seen in a game before. They're jarring so I get it, but I really like them.

@beardalaxy They don't feel integrated in the world. The style doesn't feel consistent. I would have rather they tried to emulate the style of the original concept art. At least then they could maybe justify doing a remake as the technology wasn't there to achieve the original graphical vision that they wanted. But that isn't what we got, instead we got a woman who had nothing to do with the original game deciding that because Miyamoto liked puppet theaters, to make some of the characters look like said puppets.

@WhitestTemplar I think it was an inspired decision that works really well for the dreamlike nature of the game and I don't give a single shit who came up with it.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Game Liberty Mastodon

Mainly gaming/nerd instance for people who value free speech. Everyone is welcome.