Would you trust a detective or an AI to determine your Innocence during an interigation?
@Jens_Rasmussen
> AI is impartial and neutral
I did not want to write that into the question. Actually the exact opposite, since you have no idea what data was it trained on, and who categorized them to "innocent" and "guilty".
@Jens_Rasmussen
And as autist, the idea of someone misreading my emotions scares me to death.
Well, and detective can understand the concept.... theoretically. But I cannot tell it to the AI.
@Jens_Rasmussen
@dave
But also, I am watching the interrigation videos now, and it's scary. These people are being stressed the shit out for 4 hours straight.
Who wouldn't break under such conditions?
Algorithms are often better at diagnosing that the doctors that contributed to them so I would assume that a statistical model that is was created by detectives and that has access to most of not all available crimestats would be better at guessing than the detective.
In the USA this would be a trick question. Talking to cops is almost universally a bad idea. You get a lawyer and communicate only with them present if necessary.
💀
@LukeAlmighty
Are we talking today's AI, or very futuristic AI? Cause AI has the potential to be unbiased, which could be a big benefit in such situations.
@alyx
I mean you were arrested today, and got this offer :D
@LukeAlmighty
For today, we don't have AI good enough, so it would have to be the detective.
@alyx
And you're obviously innocent
@LukeAlmighty
Sure, but we've seen over and over again that a biased detective or prosecutor can absolutely make up evidence to convict you, if that's where their bias leans to.
@alyx
I know... That's the point of the poll 
@LukeAlmighty
My answer would depend on how mature the AI is. If it were future AI, I'd pick it, but with current tech, if someone were to ask it if I were innocent, it would probably answer that I'm cheese.
Transhumans are keen to unleash the contents of this box on humanity. Gender is merely their foot jammed in the door which they forced open. I say nothing without my lawyer. I also have a right to a trial by my peers. Human PEERS.
I'll vote AI, because it's implicit in the question that the AI is impartial and neutral, but an AI actually used for that purpose would be made to have the same biases as a detective.